Table 1From “Programmatic M&A: the claim that outlived its test”
Programmatic, defined seven ways
The winning archetype's own definition, document by document. Every telling that states a threshold states a different one; the 2021 article states two; the last two state none.
Table 1Programmatic, defined seven ways
| Document | "Programmatic" means | Dataset |
|---|---|---|
| Apr 2011, McKinsey Quarterly | No winning pattern: size and frequency distributions "widely distributed and overlapping" | Top 1,000 by market cap; 917 firms, 30,000+ deals |
| Jan 2012, McKinsey Quarterly | Many small deals totalling 19% or more of market cap over the decade: the cutoff is the sample's own median | Top 1,000 nonbanking; 15,000+ deals |
| May 2018, HBR | At least one deal a year, cumulatively more than 30% of market cap over 10 years, no single deal above 30% | 2,393 largest corporations, 2010–2014 |
| Jul 2019, McKinsey Quarterly | More than two small or midsize deals a year, median 15% of market cap acquired | "Global 1,000", 2007–2017 |
| Oct 2021, fn. 3 | More than two small or midsize deals a year, total acquired "meaningful (median of 19 percent)" | "Global 2,000" |
| Oct 2021, fn. 4: same article | "A minimum of two small or midsize deals a year, with meaningful market capitalization acquired (20 percent to 30 percent)" | "Global 2,000" |
| Mar 2022 / Aug 2023 | No threshold stated: "multiple small or medium-size acquisitions" | "Global 2,000" |
Swipe or scroll horizontally if the table is wider than your screen.
Source: Author's assembly from the cited documents' own text and footnotes: Cottin, Rehm & Uhlaner (2011); Rehm, Uhlaner & West (2012), fn. 3; Bradley, Hirt, Smit & West (2018); Rudnicki, Siegel & West (2019), fn. 2; Daume, Lundberg, McCurdy, Rudnicki & Wol (2021), fn. 3 and fn. 4; Daume, Lundberg, Montag & Rudnicki (2022); Daume, Lian & McCurdy (2023). Definitions quoted or condensed from prose and footnotes only.

From the essay
Growth that compounds
Programmatic M&A: the claim that outlived its test
Every banker deck says the winners do many small deals. The claim's own shop published the null first, and the nearest test answers with conditions.
Read the essayThis exhibit belongs to an essay: the numbers live here, the argument lives there.
Cite or embed
Related exhibits

Figure 1Figure
The strongest number, and its label
Programmatic M&A: the claim that outlived its test

Table 2Table
The claim, beside its test
Programmatic M&A: the claim that outlived its test

Figure 1Figure
401(k) participation by pay band, for employees hired before automatic enrolment and under it
What is a default option?
Contact
Bring the question you're working on.
Research, a guest lecture, or a commercial question.