← Every exhibit

Figure 3From “BANT vs MEDDIC: a qualification checklist is a hypothesis”

Tight and loose lead qualification in a 1988 field test

The mailer that drew tightly qualified leads converted at four times the rate of the loose one and still ended with fewer sales.

Cite Embed

Figure 3Tight and loose lead qualification in a 1988 field test

Grouped bar chart on lead qualification from Jolson 1988, comparing tightly and loosely qualified sales leads from two mailers of 20,000 each. Leads returned: tight 104, loose 622. Appointments made: tight 66, loose 174. Presentations delivered: tight 48, loose 104. Sales from the leads: tight 32, loose 48.Tight-copy mailer (T)Loose-copy mailer (L)0100200300400500600700104622Leads returned66174Appointments made48104Presentationsdelivered3248Sales fromthe leadsCount per mailer, 20,000 sent eachGrouped bar chart on lead qualification from Jolson 1988, comparing tightly and loosely qualified sales leads from two mailers of 20,000 each. Leads returned: tight 104, loose 622. Appointments made: tight 66, loose 174. Presentations delivered: tight 48, loose 104. Sales from the leads: tight 32, loose 48.Tight-copy mailer (T)Loose-copy mailer (L)0100200300400500600700Leads returned104622Appointments made66174Presentations delivered48104Sales from the leads3248Count per mailer, 20,000 sent each

Source: Jolson (1988), p. 194, results table for mailers T and L, each sent to 20,000 small businesses on 1 September and 1 October 1987 and interlaced name by name, with results counted to 15 December 1987; conversion rates and sales values from Table 2, p. 195. One firm, six salespeople in two teams of three assigned by coin toss; no statistical test is reported.

PNG4:3, 1600 × 1200, with the title, the source line and the attribution set in the image isoglu-2026-bant-vs-meddic-fig03.png

Source and evidence

Each line names a claim related to this exhibit, its source, and how it was checked.

  • A A verified against the printed page of the primary sourceB primary source, text layer onlyC authoritative secondaryD reported Design of the 1987 field test: the author was hired as the firm's consultant; a tight mailer requesting a call about a demonstration and security analysis and a loose mailer offering a booklet, each sent to 10,000 small businesses on 1 September and 1 October 1987 (20,000 each), interlaced name by name; results counted to 15 December 1987; leads worked by six relatively inexperienced salespeople in two teams of three formed by coin toss, in a sales contest, allowed to add referrals and cold calls (pp. 193, 194): "In February 1987, the author was hired as a consultant to assist the company in introducing a direct mail circularization campaign"; "Please phone me to discuss a free demonstration and security analysis."; "Please mail me the 20-page booklet"; "of each type of circular were mailed in the firm’s market area"; "Bias was eliminated by interlacing the two types of mailers throughout the mailing list"; "it was assumed that all returns and selling activities relating to these leads would be finalized by December 15, 1987"; "All returned leads were assigned to six relatively inexperienced salespeople"; "Two teams of three people each were formed (by a coin toss), with one team assigned to work loose leads and the other to work tight leads."; "Each salesperson was promised a company-paid four-day trip to San Juan"; "the salespeople were told they were permitted to supplement their prospecting effort with customer referrals or cold calling"Jolson (1988)
  • A A verified against the printed page of the primary sourceB primary source, text layer onlyC authoritative secondaryD reported Results, read from the page images of pp. 194 and 195: leads returned 104 (tight) and 622 (loose), appointments 66 and 174, presentations 48 and 104, sales on leads 32 and 48, other sales 3 and 4; Table 2: sales from leads $64,200 and $95,320, salesperson earnings $10,144 and $12,761, sales per lead 30.8% and 7.7%, sales per presentation 66.7% and 46.2%, cost per lead $92.30 and $15.43, lead cost per sale $300.00 and $200.00; the tight team ran out of places to go; loose leads produced more volume, earnings and returns at lower cost per sale, tight leads a higher conversion rate and more motivation (pp. 194 to 196): "A Comparison of Tight vs. Loose Sales Leads"; "Almost one third of the T leads were converted into sales, whereas 13 loose leads were required for a sale."; "The sales emerging from tight leads cost 50% more."; "The T sales group seemed to run out of places to go and demonstrated little initiative and weak work habits in developing their own prospects."; "loose leads produced more sales volume, higher earnings for salespeople, a larger lead return rate, a lower lead cost per sale, and a lower compensation-cost ratio"; "Tight leads produced a higher conversion rate into sales and an increased level of motivation for sales force members."Jolson (1988)

Cite or embed

APA 7

Isoglu, S. (2026). Tight and loose lead qualification in a 1988 field test [Figure]. isoglu.com. https://isoglu.com/insights/exhibits/isoglu-2026-bant-vs-meddic-fig03/

BibTeX
@misc{isoglu-2026-bant-vs-meddic-fig03,
  author = {Isoglu, Sinan},
  title = {{Tight and loose lead qualification in a 1988 field test}},
  year = {2026},
  howpublished = {Figure 3, isoglu.com},
  url = {https://isoglu.com/insights/exhibits/isoglu-2026-bant-vs-meddic-fig03/},
  note = {From the essay {BANT vs MEDDIC: a qualification checklist is a hypothesis}}
}
Embed this exhibit

Copy this HTML to use the PNG exhibit on your site with its source line and a link back to the exhibit page.

<figure>
  <a href="https://isoglu.com/insights/exhibits/isoglu-2026-bant-vs-meddic-fig03/">
    <img src="https://isoglu.com/social/isoglu-2026-bant-vs-meddic-fig03.png" alt="Figure 3: Tight and loose lead qualification in a 1988 field test" width="3200" height="2400">
  </a>
  <figcaption>Figure 3: Tight and loose lead qualification in a 1988 field test. Source: Jolson (1988), p. 194, results table for mailers T and L, each sent to 20,000 small businesses on 1 September and 1 October 1987 and interlaced name by name, with results counted to 15 December 1987; conversion rates and sales values from Table 2, p. 195. One firm, six salespeople in two teams of three assigned by coin toss; no statistical test is reported. <a href="https://isoglu.com/insights/exhibits/isoglu-2026-bant-vs-meddic-fig03/">View exhibit</a>.</figcaption>
</figure>