Figure 16 Sept 2026From “What is reproducibility? Can another analyst reconstruct the result?”

The synthetic reconstruction worksheet

A result is ready for reconstruction only when its question, inputs, operations, environment, expected output, and mismatch state are visible.

Cite Embed

Figure 1The synthetic reconstruction worksheet

ID	Question or output	Inputs and data package	Code and environment	Expected output	Rerun state and disposition
R-01	Cohort rate at day 14	Snapshot V3 and eligibility rule held	Script S-12; runtime recorded	50.0%	Confirmed within stated tolerance
R-02	Revenue bridge by line	Invoice file held; product map version unclear	Script S-18; package lock missing	Five-effect bridge	Mismatch risk; hold release
R-03	Survey mean by locale	Data package and codebook held	Analysis script held; exclusion manual	Table of means and counts	Rerun pending exclusion log
R-04	Forecast error by horizon	Baseline and actual files held	Notebook and library versions held	Error table and plot	Confirmed; no claim of causality
R-05	Customer segment model	Access restricted; derived file only	Script available; random seed absent	Model metrics	Unavailable input; cannot reconstruct
R-06	Treatment contrast	Preregistered dataset and treatment rule held	Script and environment held	Effect estimate and interval	Reconstructed; replication still open

Swipe or scroll horizontally if the table is wider than your screen.

Source: Author's synthetic reproducibility worksheet grounded in Banzi et al. (2026) and the Open Science Collaboration (2015). All questions, artifacts, statuses, and dispositions are illustrative.

PNG4:3, 1600 × 1200, with the title, the source line and the attribution set in the image isoglu-2026-what-is-reproducibility-fig03.png

Source and evidence

Each line names a claim related to this exhibit, its source, and how it was checked.

A BNZ26-C1 A multidisciplinary consensus, in its own words: developed "by a multidisciplinary group interested in research open science and reproducibility"Banzi et al. (2026)
A BNZ26-C2 The span of the list: "core expectations regarding planning methods data col lection management and analysis and dissemination"Banzi et al. (2026)
B OSC15-C1 Ninety-seven percent of the originals were significant: "ninety sevenpercent of original studies had significant results p 05", against "thirty six percent of replications"Open Science Collaboration (2015), abstract
B OSC15-C4 Four measures, not one, and they disagree: "thirty six percent of replications had significant results", "47 of original effect sizes were in the 95 confidence interval of the replication effect size", "39 of effects were subjectively rated to have replicated the original result", and combining both "left 68 with statistically significant effects"Open Science Collaboration (2015), abstract
B R06-OWN-C1 Reproducibility asks whether another analyst can reconstruct a result from the specified question, inputs, procedures, code, environment, and outputsAuthor framework grounded in BNZ26-C1 and BNZ26-C2
B R06-OWN-C3 A reproducible workflow declares the estimand or question, input versions, transformations, analysis script, environment, random state where relevant, and expected outputAuthor framework grounded in BNZ26-C2
B R06-OWN-C6 The reconstruction worksheet should distinguish unavailable, ambiguous, rerun, mismatch, and confirmed statesAuthor operating framework
B R06-OWN-C7 The six-row worksheet is an illustrative control object and does not report a reproducibility rate for a field, company, or research communityAuthor synthetic object

Grades: A, verified against the printed page of the primary source · B, primary source, text layer only · C, authoritative secondary · D, reported.

From the essay

From the research bench

What is reproducibility? Can another analyst reconstruct the result?

Reproducibility asks whether another analyst can rebuild a result from its inputs, code, environment, and procedure. It is not replication.

6 Sept 2026

Read the essay

This exhibit belongs to an essay: the numbers live here, the argument lives there.

Cite or embed

APA 7

Isoglu, S. (2026). The synthetic reconstruction worksheet [Figure]. isoglu.com. https://isoglu.com/insights/exhibits/isoglu-2026-what-is-reproducibility-fig03/

BibTeX

@misc{isoglu-2026-what-is-reproducibility-fig03,
  author = {Isoglu, Sinan},
  title = {{The synthetic reconstruction worksheet}},
  year = {2026},
  howpublished = {Figure 1, isoglu.com},
  url = {https://isoglu.com/insights/exhibits/isoglu-2026-what-is-reproducibility-fig03/},
  note = {From the essay {What is reproducibility? Can another analyst reconstruct the result?}}
}

Embed this exhibit

Copy this HTML to use the PNG exhibit on your site with its source line and a link back to the exhibit page.

<figure>
  <a href="https://isoglu.com/insights/exhibits/isoglu-2026-what-is-reproducibility-fig03/">
    <img src="https://isoglu.com/social/isoglu-2026-what-is-reproducibility-fig03.png" alt="Figure 1: The synthetic reconstruction worksheet" width="3200" height="2400">
  </a>
  <figcaption>Figure 1: The synthetic reconstruction worksheet. Source: Author&#39;s synthetic reproducibility worksheet grounded in Banzi et al. (2026) and the Open Science Collaboration (2015). All questions, artifacts, statuses, and dispositions are illustrative. <a href="https://isoglu.com/insights/exhibits/isoglu-2026-what-is-reproducibility-fig03/">View exhibit</a>.</figcaption>
</figure>